How to make a comment on a paper

How to read and comment on a draft paper – your suggestions please

Be specific: Don't just say 'there's some good stuff in here'. Give examples: a particular sentence that is nicely written, a particularly ...

Giving an effective peer review: sample framework and comments

Give your recommendation. You can use one of the following sentences. ... "I recommend that this paper be accepted." "I recommend that this paper be accepted ...

Responding to Student Writing - Princeton Writing Program

Writing final comments · Open with a salutation. · Reflect back the paper's main point. · Discuss the paper's strengths. · Discuss the paper's weaknesses, focusing ...

How to Review a Scientific Paper in 10 Easy Steps | Proteintech Group

When writing your review, be constructive and respectful in your feedback. Clearly outline both the strengths and weaknesses of the paper, offering specific ...

How to Use Comments in Microsoft Word (Modern Comments)

Comments68. Erin Nye. Is there a way to move a modern comment (so I don't have to re-create the comment & text in another location)? Previous ...

How to Write a Peer Review - PLOS

Do · Justify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples. · Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.

Comments in Documents - Workiva Support Center

You can use the comment card or the Comments panel to manage your document's comments. If you are a Document Owner, you can create, reply to, resolve, move, ...

So You've Been Asked To Review A Paper... | Dr S J Thomson

How to Structure a Review · First paragraph: a concise one- or two-sentence summary of the paper. · Second paragraph: summarize the positive parts ...

Peer Review Writing Guide - Reviewer Resources - SAE International

The peer-review process teaches you how to review a manuscript, spot common flaws in research papers, and improve your own chances of being a successful ...

How to conduct a review - Elsevier

You should explain and support your judgement so that both editors and authors are able to fully understand the reasoning behind your comments. You should ...

How to Write Effective Peer Review Comments - YouTube

How to Write Effective Peer Review Comments. 98K views · 4 years ... Reviewing a paper for a journal (peer review). Life in academia•2.8K ...

Format for a review paper

Clearly define exactly what this article will discuss, outline the order in which you will discuss each subtopic to give the reader any background information ...

Student Peer Review, Editing, and Journal Publishing

Make note what the paper is about (mark the thesis statement and main points) and what seems confusing. This will help you determine what will ...

How to review a paper | Science | AAAS

Unless the journal uses a structured review format, I usually begin my review with a general statement of my understanding of the paper and what ...

General Comments from the Reviewers General Comments ... - TC

Comment: This is an interesting study and the authors have collected a unique dataset using cutting edge methodology. The paper is generally well written ...

Add and print comments in Pages on Mac - Apple Support

the Add Comment button . The review toolbar is visible if there are comments or tracked changes in the document. Type your comment, then click Done (or click ...

How to Write Constructive Peer Review Comments - Scholastica Blog

How to Write Constructive Peer Review Comments: Tips every journal should give referees · Take steps to avoid decision fatigue · Be cognizant of ...

Ten Simple Rules for Writing a Reply Paper - PLOS

Simmons MP (2015) Ten Simple Rules for Writing a Reply Paper. PLoS Comput Biol 11(10): e1004536. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004536

PubPeer – a website to comment on scientific papers

The authors then have a chance to respond and improve the paper, and hopefully get it accepted for publication. Pre-publication peer review has ...

A Simple Guide on How to Write a Review Paper - Studybay

How to Write a Review Paper · Check Out the Journal's Guidelines · Select the Topic · Mention Scope of the Review Paper · Evaluate the Sources of Literature ...