How to review a manuscript
How to review journal manuscripts: A lesson learnt from the world's ...
Considering the lack of a common and structured approach to evaluate manuscripts for academic journals, this study examines top-quality reviewers' ...
Reviewing Manuscripts for Peer-Review Journals
Conclusion We conclude by offering exemplar reviews of a manuscript that was ultimately accepted for publication in the journal and provide commentary on ...
There are two primary areas of concern when reviewing a manuscript, Research (the work itself) and Writing (how well the work is expressed).
How to Review a Manuscript - Jason K. Rivers, 2013 - Sage Journals
1. Do a first read-through of the paper, asking the following questions: Is the author's hypothesis or purpose for writing this paper clearly stated?
Peer review process - BioMed Central
If it does, the editorial team will select potential peer reviewers within the field of research to peer-review the manuscript and make recommendations.
How thoroughly do peer reviewers read the manuscripts ... - Quora
The Journals provide 15 days to 30 days time to review the article. If the results are novel and the article is presented to an acceptable level ...
Peer Review | Nature Portfolio
A peer reviewer can only evaluate what the authors chose to include in the manuscript. This contrasts with the expectation in the popular press that peer review ...
The Full Manuscript Review Process - SUNY Press
All scholarly books published by SUNY Press are subject to anonymous peer review and final approval of our editorial board.
Mastering the Art of a Manuscript Peer Review - SciTechEdit
Highlight Strengths. Begin your review by acknowledging the manuscript's strengths. This encourages the author and sets a positive tone for the feedback.
Learn more about reviewing manuscripts via ScholarOne through video tutorials, user guides, and FAQs. Our resources are designed to help you set up accounts ...
Instructions for Manuscript Reviewers | HJAS
For a new manuscript submission, internal reviewers are asked to recommend whether it should be declined or sent for external review. External reviewers are ...
How to review an article - Overview - Springer
Authors. Try to review the manuscript as you would like others to review your work. · Journal editors. Comment on the importance and novelty of the study.
Guidelines for Reviewers - MDPI
RB Members must review a minimum of 6 manuscripts per year. Should the reviewer be unable to provide a report when invited, they are expected to suggest ...
My peer review process - William XQ Ngiam
7. Writing the review · The summary includes a brief overview of the research manuscript – the number of experiments, the key method and measures ...
I've Been Sent a Manuscript to Review — Now What?
If you have a potential conflict of interest with respect to a submitted manuscript, let the action editor know before accepting the review ...
Conducting a Manuscript Peer Review - STFM Journals
A point-by-point approach, dividing comments into major and minor concerns. Major concerns may require substantial rewriting, more work, or the ...
A guide to becoming a peer reviewer - Editor Resources
Ethical guidelines for peer reviewers · Reviewers must give unbiased consideration to each manuscript submitted. · Reviewers must declare any conflict of interest ...
Writing an effective response to a manuscript review
One should be a point-by-point response to the referees' and AE's major and minor comments, and the other should summarize the most substantial changes and ...
Peer Review Procedures - ASHA Journals Academy
The two goals are a fair evaluation of the merit of the work, and to provide a critique that improves the manuscript. Authors expect reviews to contain an ...
Reviewer Guide - Scholastica Help Desk
Reviewers can read a manuscript, fill out the feedback form and submit their review - all through their Scholastica account.