Declining to make changes suggested by reviewers

Reviewing papers part III: Writing the review - academic life histories

In general, as a reviewer you will be given 4 choices: Reject: The paper has major flaws and is clearly unsuitable for publication, at least in ...

#42: My paper got rejected! What now? | Tress Academic

Third, decide whether you are in a position to address the suggested changes made by the reviewers of your paper. Here, you're required to make ...

Revision of your manuscript & response to reviewers

You do, however, need to address every comment in the response, so explain why you decline to follow suggestions if you do. Take your time and ...

Reviewer Fatigue? Why Scholars Decline to Review their Peers' Work

If so, the responsible editor queries the remaining reviewers via e-mail about whether they want to complete the review or be relieved of the ...

Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers - PLOS

When you make a change in response to a reviewer's comment, it can sometimes be difficult to convey to the reviewer exactly what that change ...

When (if ever) disclose your identity as a reviewer? - MathOverflow

This happened to me once - as author: the reviewer wrote some kind of open letter to the the editor and put me and my coauthor in the cc.

How do write up journal article revisions after peer review - YouTube

This video covers what to do after you receive peer review comments from an academic journal article.

When you are asked to review a paper that you've already reviewed ...

But I don't see it that way, because I don't see the editorial process as a trial. Reviewers do not have the power to reject or accept papers — ...

On rejecting feedback - Research Degree Insiders

and If you accept some changes but don't seem to address some others, you may or may not get through. But if you take the following advice, ...

When reviewing goes wrong: the ugly side of peer review - Elsevier

How to handle fake reviewers ... The recommended best practice is to always ensure, if you do employ any author-suggested referees, that papers ...

How to Revise a Journal Paper Following Reviewers Comments?

... reviewer's comment is provided. Many papers get accepted if the issues raised by the referees are addressed properly. #PostDoc #GradSchool ...

Why do peer reviewers decline to review? A survey

Lack of time is the principal factor in the decision to decline. Reviewing should be formally recognised by academic institutions and journals should ...

How to Respond to Critical Reviews - YouTube

Peer review can be a stressful process for scientific authors. How should you respond to reviewer criticisms? What if a reviewer personally ...

Peer Review Process and Differences in Reviewer ... - YouTube

Peer Review Process and Differences in Reviewer Comments in Academic Publishing. 2.2K views · 6 years ago ...more ...

Evidence - NASA Science

Earth's climate has changed throughout history. Just in the last 800,000 years, there have been eight cycles of ice ages and warmer periods, with the end of the ...

VA Decision Reviews And Appeals | Veterans Affairs

The legacy VA appeals process has changed to the decision review process ... You can appeal to the Board of Veterans' Appeals and have a Veterans ...

Breast Cancer: Screening - U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

Previously, we recommended that women in their 40s make an individual decision with their clinician on when they should start screening ...

Our Epidemic of Loneliness and Isolation - HHS.gov

resources suggested by a wide range of subject matter experts, with priority given ... connection have declined significantly in this time. Take faith ...

How to Respond to Reviewers | Research Paper - YouTube

You have completed your research project and you're now ready to submit. What do you do? If you're doing this for the first time, ...

Things that I have learned by being a journal editor

It is very common for invited reviewers to decline to review when they are on sabbatical. While I certainly have some sympathy for wanting ...