What are some good arguments against utilitarianism? Surely
Utilitarianism and Decision Procedures - PEA Soup
No statement of necessary and sufficient conditions is a decision procedure. Imagine buying a cookbook that purported to give you a procedure for making a cake, ...
God, Utilitarianism & Deontological Ethics - Building Jerusalem
Utilitarianism fails at a human level. We cannot possibly know what actions will bring about the greatest good. The only one who can truly know ...
Breaking News: Aesthetic Utilitarianism is a Sure Loser
A perennial criticism of utilitarianism is the claim that the principle of utility, if carried out consistently, would require every person to ...
'The Interview' Podcast: Peter Singer - The New York Times
His unstinting work grows out of utilitarianism, which is the view that we should do as much as possible to bring about the greatest ...
Less Utilitarian Than Thou - by Scott Alexander - Astral Codex Ten
Utilitarianism, to me, carries an implication of being able to actually in some way *calculate* what is the "greatest utility" (at least in the ...
"A Morality Fit for Humans" by Joseph Raz - Scholarship Archive
I believe that it was opposition to utilitarianism which first bred arguments claiming in one way or another that a view of morality according to which ...
Consequentialism and Utilitarianism
Thus, without reasonably thinking about my choice, I have done what it would have been reasonable to estimate would have the best results. So Expectable ...
Book Review: Utilitarianism for and against (Part 2)
Williams believes that utilitarianism merely requires someone do the right thing. This implies that to the utilitarian, there is no meaningful ...
Is Utilitarianism Viable? - Mises Institute
The fact that we are all better off if we all behave morally is utterly true and utterly irrelevant. (Such an argument violates the cherished ...
Some of the arguments you will encounter might strike you as somewhat pedantic; calculating happiness, giving away half of your salary to those ...
3. Defective Formulations of Utilitarianism a. GHP · 2. Embodies "Do the Best You Can" · 3. Impartiality · 4. Resolves Moral Dilemmas · 1. The "Too High for ...
Utilitarianism - Gareth and Emma McCaughan's web pages
It arouses strong feelings. Most proponents of utilitarianism would probably say that it's not only right, but obviously right; that those who ...
Why I'm Not a Negative Utilitarian
A thorough going Negative Utilitarian would support the destruction of the world (even by violent means) as the suffering involved would be ...
113 Utilitarianism Essay Topic Ideas & Examples - IvyPanda
In the words of Kant, utilitarianism cannot be used as a yardstick in the evaluation of human actions because it is not universal. Utilitarianism vs ...
The Discomforts of Being a Utilitarian - Quillette
After all, outright utilitarians still risk being thought of as profoundly disturbed, or at least deeply misguided. It's easy to see why: ...
Utilitarianism and Reflective Equilibrium - Philosophy, et cetera
In other words, this typically disastrous act type happened, in this particular instance, to work out for the best. So, the argument goes, ...
Utilitarianism is not unfair. Why exploiting minorities is not… - Medium
Essentially, negative utilitarians consider that negative experiences weight more than positive ones in the utilitarian calculus. If an action ...
4.1: Utilitarianism- Pros and Cons (B.M. Wooldridge)
Suppose, for instance, that George's wife and children, like George, were also against chemical and biological warfare. Utilitarianism will tell ...
Extreme and Restricted Utilitarianism | PH115: Introduction to Ethics
A restricted utilitarian would say we should always save the drowning man, however an extreme utilitarian would argue that sometimes breaking ...
Mill's Utilitarianism Part 1: John Stuart Mill's Argument for Qualitative ...
Utilitarians aren't saying that self-sacrifice isn't a good thing, only that it is not intrinsically good. What makes it good is its ...