6 ways to improve the peer review experience

A survey of seasoned peer reviewers identifies ways reviewers and the firms being reviewed can change for the better.

6 tips to secure a peer review invitation - Clarivate

Cold emailing and signing up for journals' paper-submission-database was so far the most effective method to secure peer review invitations: ...

What can we do to improve the peer review system?

From 4700 researchers, 78% think that peer review is still the best way to allocate research funds, although half of them think that it lacks transparency and ...

How could the peer review system be improved? - Quora

A very simple thing that can be done to improve peer review is to publish the referee reports alongside the paper, including the entire ...

Planning and Guiding In-Class Peer Review

Ideally, the first peer-review session should focus on a short piece of writing, such as a paragraph or two, so that students develop comfort with giving and ...

How to Be A Good Peer Reviewer - The Scholarly Kitchen

The ultimate goal is to strengthen your community of researchers. Ask yourself, “How does my review make my community stronger?” This is ...

How to Improve Your Peer Review Skills and Reputation - LinkedIn

You should also seek advice and mentorship from more experienced reviewers in your field, and participate in training or workshops on peer ...

Ten tips for a truly terrible peer review - Elsevier

Editor Bert Blocken highlights some of the major mistakes early-career researchers can make when acting as a reviewer for a journal article.

Top Tips for Peer Reviewers - Wiley Author Services

Top tips for peer reviewers · 1. Respond Promptly to Invitations · 2. Show Integrity · 3. Stay Within Scope · 4. Be Constructive · 5. Allocate Enough Time · 6. Be ...

Improving the peer-review process from the perspective of an author ...

Generally, invited reviewers do not know how many peers are involved in the review process and there is no interaction between reviewers. This ...

How do we improve peer review? - Research Information

Peer review is not perfect, and most scholars will have some personal experience of its limitations. Nevertheless, it is generally ...

Improving peer review: What reviewers can do - Oxford Academic

Do I believe it? Do I care? ... Manuscripts should clearly state the research question or clinical problem and then describe how the scholarly work was conducted.

How Can I Get the Most Out of Peer Review?

Typically, deriving points for review from the assessment criteria for the task will help students see connections between the task and its evaluation. Although ...

What makes a good or a bad peer review? Tips for excelling at ...

Authors need to know what was good about the paper and where improvements could be made. The Editor needs to know if you think the manuscript is ...

Peer Review: 5 Smart Tips for Providing Constructive Feedback

Frame your criticism positively, empower the author to improve their writing and develop ideas. Give the good news along with the bad news.

Research Methods: How to Perform an Effective Peer Review

Critical skill: Reviewers should be organized, thorough, and detailed in their critique with the goal of improving the manuscript under their ...

The 4 ways peer review is broken (and how to fix them)

Create incentives for peer review. According to Carroll, formal training on how to conduct peer reviews could help improve the quality and pace ...

10 Things You Need to Know Before You Peer Review - Wiley

1. Respond Promptly to Invitations · 2. Show Integrity · 3. Stay Within Scope · 4. Be Constructive · 5. Allocate Enough Time · 6. Be Consistent · 7. Focus on the ...

Improving the quality of Peer Review and accelerating the peer ...

Hence, it becomes essential that the editors should accelerate the peer review process, increase their reviewer's database, go for innovations and train new ...

How to Train the Next Generation to Provide High-Quality Peer ...

Journals and their editorial boards should work to mitigate unconscious bias whenever possible and improve access to trainee peer-review by ...