A template for responding to peer reviewer comments

A template for responding to peer reviewer comments - Editage

Here is a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments and concerns. Comments from Reviewer 1. [How to respond to comments that you agree with]. • Comment ...

Sample Response to Reviewers - APA Style

All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes. Reviewers' Comments to the Authors: Reviewer 1. There are numerous strengths to this ...

Response to Reviewers Template - Elsevier

Add the reviewer comments followed by author response. Make sure that the ... Response to Reviewers – OPEN PEER REVIEW. Title: Manuscript number ...

Response to reviewers template | SAGE Publications Inc

Authors are encouraged to use this template to respond to peer review comments and detail the changes made to their manuscript.

Response to Reviewers [Cover Letter] Dear Editor, We ... - GMD

[General Comment] The revision highlights the importance of model evaluation and provides a reasonable approach for evaluating the results from urban climate ...

Proper way of responding to reviewers' comments

If a reviewer repeatedly returns to the same point, it's fine to occasionally say "As mentioned above in R1.4", especially within a single ...

How to respond to peer review - a step by step guide to my first ...

I write a short paragraph thanking the reviewers for their time and state my responses to their comments are below.

Responses to Reviewer' Comments - BG

However, the manuscript is mainly a data report in the current version. There are too many methodological details but lacking appropriate discussion of the ...

Response to reviewers - APA Style

Authors should distinguish their responses from the reviewers' comments by using phrases such as “author response” and/or a different font color. Then, each ...

How to respond to reviewers' comments - EASE

For easier readability, you can separate the review comments and your responses by using a different typography. You can explain these typographical conventions ...

Q. How should I format a cover letter and response to reviewers?

[Refer to the manuscript by the number the journal assigned it.] We appreciate the helpful comments from you and the reviewers. We have ...

Free Template Response Letter to Reviewer Comments | PrintFriendly

Read the reviewers' comments thoroughly. ... Copy and paste the original comments into your response. ... Draft a clear and concise response for each comment.

How to respond to peer reviewers comments | Researcher blog

How to respond to peer reviewers comments · 1. Understand the peer review process · 2. Review all comments carefully and document the revisions · 3 ...

Responding to Peer Reviewer Comments - A Free Example

Responding to the comments peer reviewers offer when they assess your research paper can be as challenging as writing the original manuscript.

How I respond to peer reviewer comments - PMC

1. Be polite · 2. Never assume a reviewer is “stupid” or a nonexpert · 3. Respond to ALL queries and ALL author instructions · 4. Provide thorough responses · 5.

How to Write the Summary in Your Response to Reviewers [Free ...

Example Summary for Peer Reviewers · 3 Ways to Write Better Reviewer Response Summaries in English · 1. Include the important information toward ...

How to respond to reviewers' comments: A practical guide for authors

For example, you could answer, “As we received conflicting advice from another reviewer, we decided to make the change they suggested, because…. We hope this ...

How to respond to reviewer comments - Author Services

Catalogue the revisions · Mark up the changes on your document · Start with the biggest changes and be sure to track them · Update your data · Provide a diagram

Responding to peer reviewer comments | University of Dundee, UK

When you do respond, the key is to sound authoritative rather than defensive; be respectful but don't be afraid to take on board any genuinely ...

Writing a response to reviewer comments | Dynamic Ecology

Part of the process of publishing a manuscript is revising the manuscript in response to reviewer comments. Assuming you are resubmitting to ...