Best practice guidelines for peer review
Best practice guidelines for peer review - Editor Resources
Below are our best practice guidelines along with some answered questions to support you and your journal.
Peer Review – Best Practices : Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard
Separate each of your concerns clearly with line breaks (or numbering) and organize them in the order they appear in the manuscript. · Quote directly from the ...
Ethical guidelines for peer reviewers | COPE
Clear communication between the journal and the reviewers is essential to facilitate consistent, fair and timely review. Peer review, for the purposes of these ...
Best Practices for Peer Review – AUPresses Handbook for ...
The second edition of the Best Practices for Peer Review of Scholarly Books handbook was published online in September 2022.
Top Tips for Peer Reviewers - Wiley Author Services
Top tips for peer reviewers · 1. Respond Promptly to Invitations · 2. Show Integrity · 3. Stay Within Scope · 4. Be Constructive · 5. Allocate Enough Time · 6. Be ...
Peer Review Guidelines*. The goal of peer review is to help you learn to ... (Taking notes as you read, of course, is still a good idea!) o Consider ...
Peer review guidance: a primer for researchers - PMC
Although the best reviewer criteria are not listed in the editorial recommendations, it is apparent that the manuscript evaluators should be active researchers ...
Peer review best practice | SAGE Publications Inc
Reviewer feedback · Is the paper original? · Is the paper clearly written? · Is it methodologically sound; is the author's theory or argument credible? · Does the ...
A guide to becoming a peer reviewer - Editor Resources
Are you aware of, and able to follow the ethical guidelines for peer reviewers? · Do you understand the type of peer review used by the journal? · Are you aware ...
Guidelines for open peer review implementation
... best practice guidelines to guide implementation. This brief article aims to address this knowledge gap, reporting work based on an ...
Best Practices for a Peer Review at Work | Indeed.com
Best Practices for a Peer Review at Work · 1. Make it anonymous · 2. Outline expectations · 3. Leave room for feedback · 4. Review the documents ...
COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
Peer reviewers play a central and critical part in the peer- review process, but too often come to the role without any guidance and may be unaware of their ...
Peer review key principles - for editors | Emerald Publishing
Peer review should consistently follow industry standards and those set out in the respective journal guidelines, by all members of the editorial team. Clear.
Best practice—Writing a peer-review report - Oxford Academic
Editors will often send the R&R report to the author, asking for reactions to the recommendations, an indication whether they are in agreement ...
Best Practice Guidelines on Publishing Ethics - Wiley Author Services
Editors should mediate all exchanges between authors and peer reviewers during the peer-review process. Editors may seek comments from additional peer reviewers ...
Ethics for Peer Reviewers - PLOS
Basic ethical guidelines for peer reviewers · Choose assignments wisely · Provide an objective, honest, and unbiased review · Honor the ...
Best Practices Guidelines for Peer Reviewers - ASME Journal
This document provides ASME best practices guidelines for peer reviewers of manuscripts submitted to ASME Transactions Journals.
Guidelines to become a credible and constructive peer reviewer - PMC
Peer review is a learned skill set that requires knowledge of study design, review construct, ethical considerations, and general expertise in a field of study.
Peer review policies & best practices - eScholarship Support
Peer review best practices · Confidentiality and anonymity are built into the process. · The process involves at least two simultaneous reviews of ...
Handbook of Best Practices in Peer Review Published
“Best Practices for Peer Review” will serve as a core resource for the AAUP community, providing a guide for new editors in the field and new ...