Criticising the Pope is lawful

Criticising the Pope is lawful, here's how - Daily Compass

Criticising the Pope is lawful, here's how ... Criticism of the Pope is morally licit because he too can make mistakes, except when he speaks ex cathedra. The ...

Is it sinful to criticize the Pope and Vatican II? : r/Catholicism - Reddit

It depends on the nature of the criticism. Gossip, detraction, calumny, and slander are sins, and directing them at Church authorities like the pope increases ...

Is It Virtuous to Criticize the Pope? - Homiletic & Pastoral Review

Lately there has been much public criticism of our Holy Father the Pope even amongst faithful Catholics. Some have been dismayed by this ...

What are canonical penalties for criticizing the Pope?

What are canonical penalties for criticizing the Pope? According to Canon Law there no canonical penalties for criticizing a pope.

Can good Catholics criticise the Pope? - LMS Chairman

As far as criticising Popes is concerned, I would in practice urge great caution. First, any criticism which comes across as personal, or as ...

ASK FATHER: Is it a mortal sin to criticize the Pope? - Fr. Z's Blog

Criticism of the Pope can become a mortal sin if one's criticism is filled with a hatred and vitriol that shows a lack of respect or filial love for Our ...

In your opinion, how far can a Catholic reasonably go in criticizing a ...

About infallibility of Pope - it's not like everything that Pope ever say automatically need to be regarded as truth. Calling “Papal ...

"Respectful Criticism" of the Pope Quickly Morphs Into Impious Pope ...

No censure, no deletion (that we can see), no asking to tone it down or re-phrase, etc. This is the almost universal problem. Anything goes ...

Pope Francis: Popes Can Be RESPECTFULLY Criticized - Patheos

My position, which has been utterly consistent throughout my 30 years as a Catholic, is that there are legitimate times to criticize popes, but ...

On criticizing bishops—or even the Pope - Catholic Culture

Since Phil Lawler and I have devoted a little more space to criticism of Pope ... Catholic teaching is not a legitimate pastoral approach at all.

Defending the Papacy | Catholic Answers Magazine

... legitimate authority, even though they were still subject to him as Peter's successor. ... Cyprian of Carthage, criticized the pope's decisions; ...

Papal Authority and the Limits of Official Theology

It is permitted, I say, to resist [the pope] by not doing what he commands and by preventing the execution of his will. But it is not lawful to ...

A juridical-canonical perspective of internal criticism in the Church

But this consideration should not lead one to exclude criticism always and in every case, since not even the most legitimate and necessary criticism will be ...

The Church permits criticism of popes under certain circumstances

The Pope is not an absolute monarch whose thoughts and desires are law. On the contrary: the Pope's ministry is a guarantee of obedience to ...

Cardinal Burke: There are times when a Pope must be disobeyed

“The Pope must respect the deposit of faith,” Burke explained at the gathering aimed at clearing up “confusion” in the Church. “He has the ...

Criticism of the Catholic Church - Wikipedia

During its long history, the Catholic Church has been subject to criticism regarding various beliefs and practices. Within the church, this often involves ...

Convoluted trial may boil down to simple question: Is the Pope ...

At first blush, it's tempting to say that such a claim is nonsense, since the pope is an absolute sovereign. In the Catholic system, he's the ...

What's behind a growing rift between conservative U.S. Catholics ...

These bishops and cardinals aren't just disagreeing with the Pope. They're saying he's not a legitimate teacher of the faith. Some of them are ...

Pope Francis and the 'subsidiarity' of the rule of law - The Pillar

Will Arrieta's arguments be seen to address mounting criticism among bishops that — by ignoring his own legal reforms — the pope's style of ...

Pope Francis is Dividing the Church. Here's why. - YouTube

One major criticism of Pope Francis is that he has created confusion in the Church. Here are four reasons people find him confusing and what ...