Do you like Roger Waters or David Gilmour better? Why?

Do you like Roger Waters or David Gilmour better? Why? - Quora

David Gilmour. He's the better singer, he's the better musician. Take “Shine on you crazy diamond”, with just four notes David Gilmour can create an emotion ...

Instead of Roger Vs. David. What Made Waters and Gilmour Great ...

The reason you want someone like Gilmour around is that he's ... do, and show you how you can do it more effectively. That's what he ...

gilmour or waters | Steve Hoffman Music Forums

Roger more gifted with words, narrative and concept. David's solo work is prettier, easier to listen to, but intellectually lightwieght. Roger's ...

David Gilmour vs. Roger Waters - Progressive Rock Music Forum

I prefer Gilmour's musicianship and character, but theres no question Waters is the better songwriter, especially during his tenure with Floyd.

DAVID GILMOUR vs ROGER WATERS: Who Was The ... - YouTube

DAVID GILMOUR vs. ROGER WATERS: Who Was The BETTER Member Of PINK FLOYD? "The CD Guy" Johnny Z compares the contributions of David Gilmour ...

Roger Waters or David Gilmour - Progressive Rock Music Forum

He's better musician, better person. Waters may have written more great songs but Gilmour is not bad writer at all. I'd rather listen to Pink ...

Roger Waters vs David Gilmour: The Pink Floyd feud shows no sign ...

I said to Roger, “If these songs weren't good enough for The Wall [the predecessor to The Final Cut], why are they good enough now?” It ...

The deep sadness of the Roger Waters and David Gilmour feud

When something happens, we ask, “Why?” And in most cases, especially in cases of war and geopolitics, the answers are complex. It would be ...

Roger Waters vs. David Gilmour: What Caused Pink Floyd's Feud?

David Gilmour and Roger Waters' feud might be music's most legendary. As two members of Pink Floyd, along with Nick Mason and Richard Wright ...

Who sang what in Pink Floyd ? | U2 Feedback

You got it precisely right on C. Numb. And I agree, I think Dave Gilmour has a much better singing voice than Roger Waters. What about lyrics ?

Is David Gilmour of Pink Floyd really that good of a guitarist?

However, Gilmour's voice and guitar work are what made Waters' works really jump off the sheet and hit you in the heart. I love Roger Waters, ...

Pink Floyd - Who's your favorite: Gilmour or Waters - AudioKarma

That said, for me it's no contest at all: I prefer both the Gilmour led PF and "solo" Gilmour albums to "Final Cut" and Roger Waters solo albums ...

David Gilmour and Roger Waters can't agree on who was ... - Head-Fi

The emotional aspect is exactly why David is more musical. I listen to David's solo albums for the music experience.

David Gilmour On Roger Waters Rift: "I have no regrets whatsoever"

“I don't think I've done that with my own band, but I certainly did it in the post-Roger Pink Floyd, against my better judgement. The same ...

What happened between Roger Waters and David Gilmour?

You can't have Pink Floyd without Richard Wright....who funnily enough isn't even mentioned in this video and I guarantee you'll never see ...

David Gilmour vs. Roger Waters: Set List Comparison

There are plenty of nerdy time signatures, orchestral flourishes and jazzy interludes ("A Mix of Sun and Cloud"). But the best songs, like "The ...

Roger Waters - A note from Roger: There is a crappy... | Facebook

That's what I like! Roger Waters keeping it about the music. I agree with him that David's solos are some of the best in history.

DAVID GILMOUR: Roger Waters Can f**k Off! The Set List Snub

dates has announced he will not be filling his set with 1970s Floyd numbers. In otherwords, stuff written by Roger Waters If you like my ...

David Gilmour Interview - Pink Floyd and Company

... I knew of harmony and bring it slightly more mainstream, if you like. And ... I mean, I don't know what it was like for Roger because I'm not Roger ...

David Gilmour is more equal than others - Roger Waters

Look you've set me off now. No it is interesting like that whole thing of how can a person if they're an or not even just baseline moral have a ...