First time reviewing a paper!!!

First time reviewing a paper!!! : r/AskAcademia - Reddit

I am looking for some guidance and additional input about reviewing a paper for a journal. A bit of background about myself, I am a third-year Ph.D. student.

Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services

First Read Considerations · What is the main question addressed by the research? · How original is the topic? · Is the paper well written? · Are the conclusions ...

Tips for first time peer reviewers | Editage Insights

Peer reviewing a scientific manuscript can be a difficult task for first time reviewers. This article lists the main responsibilities of a peer reviewer, ...

So You've Been Asked To Review A Paper... | Dr S J Thomson

How to Structure a Review · First paragraph: a concise one- or two-sentence summary of the paper. · Second paragraph: summarize the positive parts ...

I am invited to review a paper. It is my first time. Should i accept

Consider reviewing the paper to the best of your ability, informing the editors that this is the first paper that you review and asking them ...

How to review a paper - Baker Research Group

Reviewing advice · You don't need to feel completely alone when performing your first review or two. · Your job is to give the editor advice, not ...

How to review a paper - Quora

Reviewing a paper can feel overwhelming, but here's a straightforward approach. Start by skimming the paper to get a general idea of the ...

First Time Reviewers | GEUS Bulletin

You should reject the offer to review a manuscript when the paper is totally outside of your field of expertise or experience, and where there is an actual or ...

The peer review of my first paper is just taking too long, and I ... - Quora

You might try asking a prospective journal about their typical peer review time expectations before you submit a paper to them. Depending on the ...

Is a 20 days period of time enough to review a journal paper for a ...

Reviewing a paper for the first time, even if there are lots of technical details to check, I would expect to take between two days and one ...

peer reviewing your first paper | patter - Pat Thomson

The job of reviewing is about deciding whether the paper is of sufficient quality to be published, not whether it 's the most ground-breaking piece of research ...

What's involved in reviewing an article? - Academia Stack Exchange

I've just been invited, for the first time, to review an article. The request was somewhat of a surprise to me, as I'm still a PhD student ...

A Beginner's Guide to the Peer Review System - Inside Higher Ed

After receiving a request to peer review an article, the first thing to do is to check out the journal the article was submitted to. Is the ...

Ten Tips for Performing Your First Peer Review - PubMed Central

When writing your review, we recommend beginning with a one-paragraph summary of the paper, why you think the paper is interesting, for whom, ...

Peer-Review Techniques for Novices | Science | AAAS

His first piece of advice for novices is to "look at the journal in question, find a paper that is reasonably close to your own work and review it for practice.

How to conduct a review - Elsevier

If you don't spot any major flaws, take a break from the manuscript, giving you time to think. Consider the article from your own perspective. When you sit down ...

A guide to becoming a peer reviewer - Editor Resources

Before you review · Are you aware of, and able to follow the ethical guidelines for peer reviewers? · Do you understand the type of peer review used by the ...

Peer Review Writing Guide - Reviewer Resources - SAE International

It is important to read the manuscript through to make sure you are a good fit to assess the research. Also, the first read through is significant because this ...

Tips for first time peer reviewers: How to review a scientific manuscript

We discussed some of the concerns that first time reviewers have and how they should go about deciding whether to accept a peer review request.

How to Review Articles | SAGE Publications Inc

... journal access offered to reviewers of articles for Sage journals. If you are an inexperienced or first-time reviewer, the peer review process may seem daunting ...