Guidelines For Article Reviewers
Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services
What is the main question addressed by the research? · How original is the topic? · Is the paper well written? · Are the conclusions consistent with the evidence ...
A guide to becoming a peer reviewer - Editor Resources
Reviewers should provide a constructive, comprehensive, evidenced, and appropriately substantial peer review report. Reviewers are responsible for ensuring any ...
How to conduct a review - Elsevier
Giving your overall opinion and general observations of the article is essential. Your comments should be courteous and constructive, and should not include any ...
Guidelines For Article Reviewers - F1000Research
Is the work clearly and accurately presented? Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations to the current literature? Are any ...
How to Perform a Peer Review - Wiley Author Services
You've received or accepted an invitation to review an article. Now the work begins. Here are some guidelines and a step by step guide to help you conduct your ...
Guidelines for Reviewers - MDPI
Until the article is published, reviewers should keep the content of the manuscript, including the Abstract, confidential. Reviewers should also be careful not ...
Reviewer Guidelines - Research Involvement and Engagement
Peer review is a process used to assess the validity, significance and originality of research before publication in a scientific journal.
Reviewer Guidelines - Discover Journal Series - Springer
General Guidance · The following conventions should be respected: · Reviewers should review the peer review policy of the Journal before revealing their ...
Guidelines for reviewers - American Psychological Association
Preferred format: numbered list with no more than about 5–10 items. Minor Points: List any other problems, weaknesses, errors, omissions, or limitations that ...
Peer Review Guidelines Its Essential And Clear Do And Don'ts
Any selected referee who feels unqualified to review the research reported in a paper, or knows that its prompt review will be impossible should notify the ...
Guidelines For Article Reviewers | Gates Open Research
Peer review of articles on Gates Open Research takes place after publication; once the article is published, expert reviewers are formally invited to review.
Guidelines for Reviewers | Research - Science Partner Journals
Only some of the papers submitted to Science Partner Journals are reviewed in depth. Reviewers may be selected to evaluate separate components of a manuscript.
Guidelines for Reviewers | PLOS ONE
Writing the review · What are the main claims of the paper and how significant are they for the discipline? · Are the claims properly placed in the context of the ...
Best practice guidelines for peer review - Editor Resources
Key to this is to make sure that peer review reports are sourced from at least two independent referees, for every original research article we publish.
Guidelines for reviewers - American Psychological Association
First, the authors must be potentially able to appropriately address all serious issues within the manuscript. Any serious issue that is unable to be ...
Review Criteria: All AGU Journals
The criteria include questions on research significance, methods, data and its availability, appropriate referencing, presentation, and key points.
How to Review Articles | SAGE Publications Inc
Peer review is essential for filtering out poor quality articles by assessing the validity and integrity of the research.
Guidelines for Reviewers - Optica Publishing Group
A review should be as constructive and helpful as possible; in no case is subjective personalized criticism appropriate in a review. Reviewers should explain ...
The writing of the manuscript should be clear and concise. The content should be backed by prior scientific literature, providing citations and references of ...
Guide for reviewers | Oxford Open Neuroscience
Your comments should be professional and courteous and should help the author to improve their paper and present their research as clearly and concisely as ...