How to Write a Peer Review Report

1. Summary of the research and your overall impression. In your own words, summarize what the manuscript claims to report. · 2. Discussion of ...

Peer Review Writing Guide - Reviewer Resources - SAE International

Make sure to include feedback on the strengths, as well as the weaknesses, of the manuscript. Examples and explanations of those should consume most of the ...

Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services

After the initial read and using your notes, including those of any major flaws you found, draft the first two paragraphs of your review - the first summarizing ...

How to Write a Peer Review for a Journal Article - Jen Jack Gieseking

How to Write a Peer Review for a Journal Article · I begin by writing three sentences about what I think the paper is about. · I look over my ...

Any golden rules for writing peer-review comments? : r/AskAcademia

I agree with pretty much everything said here: be kind, professional, honest. Don't forget you've been asked to review for a reason, probably ...

How to Write a Peer Review: Giving Constructive Feedback - Lattice

Structuring Your Feedback · Strengths: What does this employee do well, and how does that contribute to the success of the team? · Areas for ...

What makes a good or a bad peer review? Tips for excelling at ...

What does a good peer review look like? ... 1. Start with a (very) brief summary of the paper. This is a useful exercise for both reviewers and ...

4 Steps to the Perfect Peer Review Report - MDPI Blog

The peer review report should identify an overall benefit to the work being published and available to readers. This can be determined by asking ...

Peer Review – Best Practices : Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard

Most commonly the format is (1) Summary, (2) Decision, (3) Major Concerns, and (4) Minor Concerns (see also Structure Diagram above). There is also often a ...

How to Write Constructive Peer Review Comments - Scholastica Blog

How to Write Constructive Peer Review Comments: Tips every journal should give referees · Take steps to avoid decision fatigue · Be cognizant of ...

How to write a peer review report - F1000

Here, we share how to write a peer review report that offers the author constructive feedback to improve their research.

HOW TO WRITE AN EFFECTIVE PEER REVIEW REPORT

GOAL: A peer review report has two purposes, and two different audiences. 1. To help the journal editor(s) decide ...

(for reviewers) How to write a high-quality peer review

Anatomy of a high-quality peer review · Summary or Overview: (optional) Begin the report with a concise summary of the paper's main findings, ...

Writing a Peer Review Report - JAMS Blog

In this article, we'll be covering the ways that a reviewer can provide the best report they can, and how you can incorporate these ideas into your own peer ...

Peer Reviewing Tips - F1000Research

Below, experienced peer reviewers share their tips for writing a good peer review report. In addition, we have selected several peer review reports from papers ...

How to draft a journal peer review report: easy steps to get you started

We've put together this handy guide to writing a review for a journal article, to help you craft the kind of review that is most useful to journals as well as ...

How to Write a Peer Review Report - Enago Academy

To be a good peer reviewer you need to be an expert in your field, be fair to the author and journal, meet deadlines, be honest in your opinion, and kind in ...

How to write an effective peer review report (for humanities & social ...

The first thing a peer review report needs to do is to identify what the manuscript's main argument is, what its methods are, and how these are situated.

So You've Been Asked To Review A Paper... | Dr S J Thomson

How to Structure a Review · First paragraph: a concise one- or two-sentence summary of the paper. · Second paragraph: summarize the positive parts ...

Best practice guidelines for peer review - Editor Resources

To avoid the possibility of bias compromising the decision-making process, it is important to get reports from two independent peer reviewers for every ...