How to disagree with a reviewer?

Can say no to a reviewer comment? (Journal submission) - Reddit

I appreciate you taking the time to review my work. I understand that you don't agree with (insert statement of disagreement) however without ...

How to disagree with a reviewer? - ResearchGate

The key is to be polite and to provide a sound argument demonstrating your grounds for the disagreement. Daniel Wright is right. Although you ...

How I respond to peer reviewer comments - PMC

If you disagree with a reviewer, that is fine. As an author, one of my favorite points of disagreement with reviewers is when a reviewer asks me to add P ...

What do you do if you don't agree with the reviewer's comments on ...

Thank them politely for sharing their opinion and ask what you could do to make it better. Keep what is useful and ignore the rest. If this is ...

Declining to make changes suggested by reviewers

Nearly always, it's better to publish the paper that best explains your research, so don't be afraid to say you won't make a change if that change won't clearly ...

What can I do when I can't agree with the reviewer's comments?

Disagreeing with reviewer comments in rebuttal letter.

How to react to unfair reviewer comments?

You can definitely mention that the reviewer disagrees with the other reviewers, but don't say anything about motives to the editor - there is ...

How should I respond to a comment where the reviewer has failed to ...

It is alright to disagree with a reviewers comment if you feel that your idea is justified. You can politely explain your perspective to the ...

How to respond to peer reviewers comments | Researcher blog

Remember, peer review is a discussion. It's okay to politely disagree with the reviewer (and the editor) if you have a good reason. If there ...

Proper way of responding to reviewers' comments

Disagree - no revision: Used when I disagree and see no way to improve the paper from the comment. Disagree - revised anyway: Used when I ...

How to respond to comments you disagree with? | CW Authors

If you get peer review comments back on your work that you disagree with, stay calm. The most important thing is to remain polite and constructive in your ...

How to respond to difficult or negative peer-reviewer feedback - Nature

Waiting a day or two to respond to reviewer comments can help to create emotional distance between yourself and your work.

Sample Response to Reviewers - APA Style

Author response: While we appreciate the reviewer's feedback, we respectfully disagree. We think this study makes a valuable contribution to the field ...

It's a tie! How to deal with conflicting recommendations from reviewers

If the disagreements are slight, you may well be able to reconcile the differences and decide either to deprioritize one party's feedback, or ...

Q. What do I do if I disagree with a grant reviewer?

Write the Introduction to the resubmission. For most NIH grants, this is a single page that summarizes your response to each reviewer comment.

How best to rebut a peer-reviewer who is clearly wrong?

If you disagree with some of the comments, provide your reasons for doing so. Cite. 15 Recommendations.

How to respond to reviewers' comments: A practical guide for authors

End the letter to the reviewer with a sentence such as, “We would like to thank the referee again for taking the time to review our manuscript.” How to reply to ...

Effectively and adequately responding to reviewers' and editors ...

Address all the comments: Even if you disagree with any of the reviewers' comments, make sure to respond to all of them. Be prepared to defend ...

How to respond to reviewers' comments: A practical guide for authors

You should always be tactful when answering to peer review comments, but especially so when you disagree with the reviewer. To support your argument, you may ...

5 Tips for Handling Peer Review Disagreements in Journal Publishing

This write-up will delve deeper into the nature of disagreements in peer review and discuss strategies to enhance collaboration and feedback between reviewers ...