How to respond to questions by reviewers?

Proper way of responding to reviewers' comments

Try to make each Reviewer's section self-contained. If a reviewer repeatedly returns to the same point, it's fine to occasionally say "As ...

How I respond to peer reviewer comments - PMC

1. Be polite. It can be tempting to respond with spite about specific reviewer comments. Rather than saying something like, “The reviewer is incorrect on this ...

Sample Response to Reviewers - APA Style

Response to Reviewers ... We think this study makes a valuable contribution to the field because [describe the knowledge gained, insights provided, questions ...

How do you deal with reviewer comments when they don't seem like ...

In the response to reviewers, I usually explicitly say something like "we agree that this is a concern, we originally tried to address it in the ...

How to respond to questions by reviewers? - Editage

Start your responses with a polite acknowledgment of the reviewer's feedback. Thank them for their time and insights. Address each question ...

A template for responding to peer reviewer comments - Editage

We look forward to hearing from you in due time regarding our submission and to respond to any further questions and comments you may have. Sincerely,. [name ...

How to respond to peer reviewers comments | Researcher blog

Throughout your response, maintain a respectful and professional tone. End your response by expressing your gratitude once again for the ...

How to respond to reviewer comments - Author Services

9 steps on how to respond to reviewer comments · Catalogue the revisions · Mark up the changes on your document · Start with the biggest changes and be sure to ...

How to respond to a reviewer's comment asking to add irrelevant ...

What do you mean? · Decide if this comment is relevant to you and how, in what way? · If you can't answer those questions in an immediate way in ...

How to respond to reviewers' comments: A practical guide for authors

How to reply to peer review comments when submitting papers for publication. The length of a response depends on the complexity of the question. I've edited ...

Response to reviewers - APA Style

Authors should distinguish their responses from the reviewers' comments by using phrases such as “author response” and/or a different font color. Then, each ...

Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers - PLOS

Provide a “yes” or “no” answer whenever possible. When the reviewer is correct, state so in your response. Your goal is to show the reviewer ...

Responding to Peer Reviewers: You Can't Always Say What ... - AJE

It is important to maintain a positive, cordial tone even when reviewers clearly misunderstood or did not read your work carefully. Updated on ...

Critical Tips on How to Respond to Peer Reviewers - PMC - NCBI

Be polite, but do not repeat thanks in every response. As the old Korean proverb says, excessive politeness becomes rudeness. If you agree with ...

How to respond to peer review comments? - Wiley

When replying to peer review comments, you are expected to be polite and respectful in your response. It can be a good idea to wait for a day or ...

Questions Answered: 'How to Respond to Reviewer Comments ...

Attendees were guided through the nuances of crafting thoughtful, strategic, and constructive responses to peer reviewer feedback.

Writing a response to reviewer comments | Dynamic Ecology

In the Response to Reviewer document, you should paste all the comments from the reviewers, and then put your responses immediately below each ...

How to Reply to Reviewers?

Give a brief summary in the reply of how you addressed the concern, and if necessary indicate the lines in the new text with the relevant ...

Responding to peer reviewer comments | University of Dundee, UK

When you do respond, the key is to sound authoritative rather than defensive; be respectful but don't be afraid to take on board any genuinely ...

How to respond to reviewers' comments on manuscripts submitted ...

Address each comment directly: Respond to each comment directly, and explain how you have addressed the reviewers' concerns in your revised ...