How to write a thorough peer review

How to write a thorough peer review - Nature

A peer-review workflow to guide reviewers in delivering useful and thorough analyses that can really help authors to improve their papers.

How to write a thorough peer review | IiSGM

peer-reviewing papers, says Mathew Stiller-Reeve. Mathew Stiller-Reeve. Page 2. 17/10/2018. How to write a thorough peer review https://www ...

How to Write a Peer Review - PLOS

Do · Justify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples. · Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.

Peer Review Writing Guide - Reviewer Resources - SAE International

Make sure to include feedback on the strengths, as well as the weaknesses, of the manuscript. Examples and explanations of those should consume most of the ...

How to Write Constructive Peer Review Comments - Scholastica Blog

IOP advises reviewers to “focus on facts rather than feelings, slow down your decision making, and consider and reconsider the reasons for your ...

This is embarrassing, but how do you do a peer-review? - Reddit

My peer reviews tend to be about one page (if the original paper was empirical) and have three paragraphs. My first paragraph overviews the ...

What makes a good or a bad peer review? Tips for excelling at ...

What does a good peer review look like? ... 1. Start with a (very) brief summary of the paper. This is a useful exercise for both reviewers and ...

How to write a thorough peer review for a scientific publication? Are ...

Identify and define the topic that you will be reviewing. · Read through the research that you have found and take notes. · Organize your notes ...

How to write a peer review report - F1000

Peer reviewing tips · Read the article multiple times · Be thorough and specific · Consider the statistics · Organize your comments · Be constructive ...

How to Write a Peer Review: 12 things you need to know - Clarivate

12-step guide to writing a peer review · 1) Make sure you have the right expertise. · 2) Visit the journal web page to learn their reviewer- ...

(PDF) How to write a thorough peer review - ResearchGate

A peer-review workflow to guide reviewers in delivering useful and thorough analyses that can really help authors to improve their papers.

Understanding peer review - Author Services - Taylor & Francis

Then, the reviewers who do accept the request, have to find time alongside their own research, teaching, and writing, to give your paper thorough consideration.

Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services

When you receive an invitation to peer review, you should be sent a copy of the paper's abstract to help you decide whether you wish to do the review. Try to ...

Peer Reviewing a Scientific Paper: Strategies for a Thorough Analysis

A thorough analysis during peer review involves evaluating the paper's originality, significance to the field, methodological soundness, and the clarity and ...

How to Write a Peer Review for a Journal Article - Jen Jack Gieseking

How to Write a Peer Review for a Journal Article · Before I go on, my first tip is that each peer review should take no more than two to six ...

Don't be cruel: how to write a fair peer review report

When reviewing a manuscript, always remember to focus on what the submission is, not what the submission could have been. While a peer reviewer ...

How to Write a Peer Review Report - Enago Academy

Briefly describe the main research question and conclusion, as well as the relevance to the journal. Give its overall strengths and quality as well as any major ...

A Peer Review Process Guide - GEUS Bulletin

This worksheet has been compiled from the advice of a number of journals and publications. The aim of the worksheet is to give less-experienced peer ...

Research Methods: How to Perform an Effective Peer Review

Critical skill: Reviewers should be organized, thorough, and detailed in their critique with the goal of improving the manuscript under their ...

How to draft a journal peer review report: easy steps to get you started

Give 1-2 examples to support your criticisms, and suggest concrete steps that the authors can take to remedy any defects. Example: Avoid: “ ...