One Interview Reviewer's Advice
One Interview Reviewer's Advice - HOW TO TELL A STORY - Reddit
Every answer in an interview where you're telling a story should address 1. what happened, 2. what your response/feelings were, 3. what you learned, and 4. how ...
But I would caution against offering too much detail in a (semi)public forum or lingering in this phase for too long. It's a small world—and ...
Twelve Tips for Reviewers - Association for Psychological Science
Twelve Tips for Reviewers · 1. Know your mission. · 2. Be speedy. · 3. Read carefully. · 4. Say positive things in your review. · 5. Don't exhibit ...
Understanding Reviewer Feedback: Guidelines and Explanations
Thank the reviewers for their feedback. · Reiterate the reviewers main recommendations as well as the title of your submission. · Address tasks or questions the ...
Proper way of responding to reviewers' comments
To this end, I use a different color for reviewer comments and my responses. I use a bullet list to highlight key facts. Further, I include ...
How to disagree with a reviewer? - ResearchGate
You always can objectively respond each of reviewers' comments. The editor and reviewer will make decision for the manuscript according to the ...
Give yourself some time to feel those emotions. · Come up with a plan for responding to reviews, then bird by bird it. · As much as possible, try ...
How to respond to questions by reviewers? - Editage
Start your responses with a polite acknowledgment of the reviewer's feedback. Thank them for their time and insights. Address each question directly and ...
An Interview With Reviewers 1, 2, and 3 | Savage Minds
Reviewer 1: Well, this sort of gets at a philosophy of reading–I basically try to say “yes” whenever I come across something so that I can ...
Do new authors need to agree to every suggestion of reviewers if ...
Not every single suggestion, but most. Certainly don't expect to get your paper published if you ignore the suggestions/recommendations of the ...
Tips for first time peer reviewers: How to review a scientific manuscript
For one, you have to be completely objective and unbiased in your evaluation. In addition, you need to have the necessary expertise in the field ...
Choosing Reviewers for Paper | ResearchGate
(And, I would advise, if you are asked to find, or even suggest, reviewers, check very carefully to make sure that the journal is really a top ...
Working with Editors - Wiley Author Services
Comments to Editors and Authors ... The editor not only uses reviewer comments to help make a decision. They will often refer to them in their decision letter.
Responding to Reviewers: Tips for New Authors
Step One: Begin your response with a statement of appreciation and maintain this polite and appreciative tone throughout your response. Step Two: Itemize the ...
Lessons from a Prolific Peer Reviewer: Interview with Jonas Ranstam
The aim was to promote and support younger colleagues as reviewers. I think this was a good initiative. My best advice to early career ...
How to conduct a review - Elsevier
As a peer reviewer you ... The editor will weigh all views and may call for another opinion or ask the author for a revised paper before making a decision.
Reviewers Just Butchered Your Draft. Do You Push Back ... - Fenwick
The real work begins after you've made your decision to push back—the challenge becomes conveying your counterargument in a way that makes ...
A reviewer's advice on constructing and delivering a good-quality ...
During the interview Nnamdi explains why he reviews, the benefits of being a reviewer, and how his relationship with Emerald helped him in his academic career.
Key Guidelines for Responding to Reviewers - PMC - NCBI
We carefully considered the reviewer's suggestions and have revised our paper accordingly. Specific revisions include: 1. Addition of some tips and advice ...
Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services
When you receive an invitation to peer review, you should be sent a copy of the paper's abstract to help you decide whether you wish to do the review. Try to ...