Peer review bias and double|blind reviewing

Reviewer bias in single- versus double-blind peer review - PNAS

This information asymmetry persists through the process of bidding for papers, reviewing papers, and entering scores. Reviewers in the single-blind condition ...

Reviewer bias in single- versus double-blind peer review - PubMed

Peer review may be "single-blind," in which reviewers are aware of the names and affiliations of paper authors, or "double-blind," in which ...

Peer review bias and double-blind reviewing: a new study

For all the strengths of our peer review system, there are reasons to worry that it has flaws too. One important worry is that peer ...

Double-blind Peer Review... What are the benefits and drawbacks?

By having a double-blind review, it eliminated this happening. It is no secret that gender bias still remains in reviewing. An experiment ...

Research Integrity and Peer Review - BioMed Central

In double-blind peer review neither authors nor reviewers know the identity of the others. Double-blinding should reduce the status bias and ...

Double‐blind peer review affects reviewer ratings and editor ...

Double-blind review reduced the average success of manuscripts in peer review; papers reviewed with author identities blinded received on ...

Double-Blind Reviews: A Step Toward Eliminating Unconscious Bias

Proponents of double-blind review suggest that it is a more impartial process that limits biases and results in higher quality peer reviews.

Peer review: Single blind vs double blind - Ex Ordo

Another benefit of double blind is it reduces the possibility of reviewer bias. Bias can take many forms, for example an author's gender, ...

Single-Blind and Double-Blind Peer Review | CW Authors

Advocates of double-blind peer review argue that it goes further towards reducing the possibility of bias in the peer review process. Anyone ...

Single-Blind Vs. Double-Blind Peer Review - Simple Guide

Double-blind reviews mean that the authors and reviewers are both unaware of the others' identity. In open peer reviews, all parties are ...

Does double-blind peer review reduce bias? Evidence from a ... - arXiv

Therefore, an intuitive solution to reduce reviewing bias is to adopt the so-called double-blind peer review (7), in which both the authors and the reviewers ...

Single-Blind Vs. Double-Blind Peer Review - Enago Academy

It is important that this process is not tainted by reviewer bias. Two popular modes of review exist. In single-blind peer review, the authors ...

Peer Review Bias: A Critical Review - Mayo Clinic Proceedings

A compelling ethical and moral rationale necessitates improving the peer review process. A double-blind peer review system is supported on equipoise and fair- ...

Types of Peer Review - AJE

Double-blind peer review is a process used by academic journals to ensure articles submitted for publication are fairly reviewed by experts in ...

The Fractured Logic of Blinded Peer Review in Journals

Double-blind peer review puts its chips on the first of those to reduce socially prejudiced decisions and protect peer reviewers from the ...

Peer Review Bias: A Critical Review - Mayo Clinic Proceedings

A compelling ethical and moral rationale necessitates improving the peer review process. A double-blind peer review system is supported on ...

Double-blind peer review affects reviewer ratings and editor ...

However, the effectiveness of double-blind peer review in eliminating biases is uncertain because few randomized trials have manipulated blinding of author ...

Double-anonymous review is an effective way of combating status ...

To reduce these biases and make peer review fairer, some journals have adopted double-anonymous peer review, peer review in which the reviewers ...

Double-anonymous peer review reduces reviewer bias, finds three ...

A trial of double-anonymous peer review methods in academic journals addresses possible biases and seeks to improve equity in publishing.

Does double-blind peer-review reduce bias? Evidence ... - NASA ADS

... reviewing policy from single-blind peer review to double-blind peer review in 2018. We find that after switching to double-blind review, the scores given to ...