- Plato's Argument Against Writing🔍
- In “Phaedrus🔍
- Plato's Surprising Argument Against Writing🔍
- Plato's Philosophical Answer to the Three Deficiencies of the Written ...🔍
- Socrates on the Invention of Writing and the Relationship of Writing ...🔍
- Was Socrates right in his arguments against writing? Why or why not?🔍
- Plato rejects writing by the mouth of Socrates🔍
- Socrates' Critique of Writing in Plato's Phaedrus🔍
Plato's Argument Against Writing
Plato's Argument Against Writing - Farnam Street
Plato's Argument Against Writing. “Tell me and I'll forget; show me and I may remember; involve me and I'll understand.” ... From Plato's Phaedrus, commenting on ...
To Socrates, the problem with writing is not that it “creates forgetfulness in the learners” but that people mistakenly hold the written word up ...
In “Phaedrus,” Plato appears to discredit the idea of communicating ...
Plato seems to suggest that writing is an ineffective means of teaching because readers are not thinking for themselves - just reading the words of another.
Plato's Surprising Argument Against Writing - The Apeiron Blog
This directly opposes the ancient advice of Plato. In 370 BCE, he actively encouraged others to stop writing things down.
True Stuff: Socrates vs. the Written Word - Wondermark
By no means. ... Then he will not, when in earnest, write them in ink, sowing them through a pen with words which cannot defend themselves by ...
Plato's Philosophical Answer to the Three Deficiencies of the Written ...
The first is that writing inhibits the cultivation of memory, making one dependent on orthographic conventions, onto which, in turn, our ideas ...
Socrates on the Invention of Writing and the Relationship of Writing ...
In the process Socrates faulted writing for weakening the necessity and power of memory, and for allowing the pretense of understanding, rather than true ...
Was Socrates right in his arguments against writing? Why or why not?
For the sake of historical purposes, it bothers me on a personal level, as a Socrates fan I would have liked to have his ideas written by ...
Plato rejects writing by the mouth of Socrates
This is the main objection of Plato. The second is that writing weakens and destroys memory and become forgetful men because the writing is not ...
Socrates' Critique of Writing in Plato's Phaedrus - Crossings
The assignment was to write an essay, which critically analyzes. Socrates' critique of writing in Plato's Phaedrus. ... Luddite, I am not arguing entirely against ...
Plato's Critique of Writing in the Phaedrus | shared ignorance
Plato seems to have been convinced that writing could never be a sufficient vehicle for communicating knowledge directly.
Plato writes on the dangers of writing. - Document - Gale
Plato is an outspoken critic of writing when it replaces dialectic. He charges that it is easy for texts to fall into the hands of the untutored who are led to ...
274 B - 277 A - Plato: Phaedrus
While he seems to recognize the entertainment value of writing, Socrates does not believe that written words, alienated from the living presence of their ...
Rhetoric and Reading: Plato's Socrates on the Viability of Written ...
keep a solemn silence.”[5] No matter how forcefully one might address the text, it will not respond to the specific inquiry of the reader.
Socrates: Writing vs. Memory | ETEC540: Text Techologies
Throughout his discussion with a colleague, Socrates insists that writing destroys memory and weakens the mind (Ong, 2002). To support his ...
Plato versus Literature | Issue 161 | Philosophy Now
Curmudgeonly old Plato means that literature has deceived us. So in fact, it has done the exact opposite of saving us: it has wantonly misled us. For want of a ...
Plato Would Like To Remind You: Writing Is A Technology, Not A ...
For Plato, writing was a form of technology, and one that threatened basic, human cognitive capacities like our ability to think, remember, and know the true ...
Socrates on the Forgetfulness that Comes with Writing
Socrates did not write down any of his thoughts, however his dialogues were recorded by his student and protégé, the philosopher Plato (428 – 347 BCE). Here ...
Notes on Plato's Phaedrus (2/2) Argument Against Rhetoricians and ...
The simplest way to approach the fact that the Phaedrus is effectively a written argument against the written word is to say that Plato was ...
A Defense of Plato on Writing Seriously Written
The critique against writing is its pretense to understanding, a mere image of understanding. It could hardly matter whether we could literally see this image.