- Reviewers don't even bother to read your manuscript 🔍
- Do journal reviewers often badly understand the papers they review?🔍
- ask a scatterbrain🔍
- What does an editor do when she doesn't understand any of ...🔍
- Why aren't editors reading?🔍
- Reviewing papers for MDPI🔍
- Apparently a reviewer doesn't actually have to read the book they're ...🔍
- Reviewer Guide🔍
Reviewers don't even bother to read your manuscript
Reviewers don't even bother to read your manuscript : r/academia
Reviewers don't always want to admit that they didn't understand a paper. Some ideas are hard to communicate or are communicated poorly.
Do journal reviewers often badly understand the papers they review?
As a peer reviewer, your review will be scrutinized by the author(s) of the manuscript and the editor of the journal. Each will be very ...
There's nothing to salvage, and no burden on the reviewer to basically rewrite the paper. Editorial discretion should have prevented the thing ...
What does an editor do when she doesn't understand any of ... - Quora
If an editor doesn't understand any of the reviewers' or authors' responses to her feedback on their manuscript, she should take the time to ...
Why aren't editors reading? - John Measey
It's not surprising that the editors have little to nothing to say; without reading the manuscript, the reviewer comments aren't really very ...
Reviewing papers for MDPI: general feeling as a reviewer
I even reveiced "reviews" from reviewers while it was obvious they hardly bothered to read my paper, but MDPI seems to top the cake to be honest ...
Apparently a reviewer doesn't actually have to read the book they're ...
It is up to the author to make the book so readable that, once having read the Sample the reader won't stop there. If it is obvious the reviewer ...
Reviewer Guide - Scholastica Help Desk
Reviewers can read a manuscript, fill out the feedback form and ... Perhaps worse, you don't even see a My Reviews button in the navigation bar.
Is it normal that my Journal submission is "With Editor" after a month?
It's saddening that after long delay by some Editors, they keep the manuscript without sending out for review process and worse still after it's ...
First rule of book club? Don't read the book | TheArticle
But even this insight seems incomplete. Along with solitude and quiet, don't you also need something to read? Sir Roger Scruton argued that ...
Get Your Book Reviewed | Kirkus Indie Reviews
After reading your review, you will be able to publish it on Kirkus.com simply by clicking a button. At that point, the review will be considered for ...
Difficulty In Finding Reviewers Taints Editorial Decisions
Finding willing academics to review a manuscript is getting more difficult for some journals. Unfortunately, this difficulty may also be ...
Critics and Reviewers - George R.R. Martin
To be blunt, if a book reviewer shows, a consistent pattern of error, distortion, and half-truth in review after review he or she ought not to be published. Not ...
Alpha and Beta Readers: What Are They and Why Bother?
However, you don't have to pay someone to read your work. You can ... review your manuscript/piece/work. The more you work with alpha ...
A Sense of Agency: A Conversation with Lauren Oyler
The essays on autofiction and vulnerability in the collection are the result of having read both a lot of book reviews and a lot of reviews of ...
Advance Reader Copies: Understanding the Rules and Restrictions ...
ARC Teams – read and review the book early. ... I do not eliminate people based on social media status or past reviews (even past reviews of my ...
I've written a book…. now what? - Compulsive Readers
... read what you have written, why would anybody else? 2. To plan or not to plan? Writers are generally classified as pantsers (who don't bother ...
don't think you should comment on this review, even to thank the reviewer.'” Most authors I know read their Goodreads reviews, and then silently ...
Critical Attrition | Issue 40 | n+1 | The Editors
Worth the read.” — The Major Times Book Review. Back to our reader. He gets ... So why are all these critics still so riled up? Without realizing it ...
Peer Review Process - Wiley Author Services
As stated previously, it is very rare that a paper will be accepted without any form of revisions requested. It is the job of the editor and reviewer to make ...