Reviewing a review
Reviewing review articles, part 2: The how - Cell Mentor - Cell Press
Yes, review articles are peer-reviewed! Submitting to a Trends journal requires an affirmative from the editor in some form.
Reviewing review articles | Springer — International Publisher
The review article should present an unbiased summary of the current understanding of the topic, and therefore the peer reviewer must assess the selection of ...
Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services
Our step-by-step guide to conducting a review will help you through the processes of reviewing the paper, structuring your report, providing criticisms and ...
5 tips for reviewing a review article - Cell Mentor - Cell Press
We present five tips every peer reviewer should consider when reviewing a review article. 1. Understand the journal's requirements.
So You've Been Asked To Review A Paper... | Dr S J Thomson
It's easy to treat reviewing a paper as some sort of homework excerse, e.g. 'Find all the flaws in this paper!', and return a review that looks ...
Reviewing a review | Nature Reviews Psychology
For a Review, discussion of major theories or findings should be balanced, and any intentional omissions should be explained to the reader. For ...
How to conduct a review - Elsevier
Reviewing can be a lot of work — before you commit, make sure you can meet the deadline. Do you need to find out more about reviewing and the peer review ...
Reviewing the Review Process: An Author and Editor Perspective
This article contributes to the literature by providing unique insights from the perspectives of both editors and authors.
Points to Consider When Reviewing Articles - Yale School of Medicine
Reviews provide a reasoned survey and examination of a particular subject of research in biology or medicine. These can be submitted as a mini-review (less than ...
'Another look' at peer review: reviewing review articles - the Node
Most reviews should guide the reader through the article and provide all the necessary background to make links in thought between data and ...
How to Review Articles | SAGE Publications Inc
Editors can rate your reviews which may increase your chances of being invited to review again. 2. Contact the journal editor or editorial office directly. In ...
3.3 How to peer review a review article
Matt Pavlovich is the editor of Trends in Biotechnology, Cell Press's home for reviews in applied biology. He earned his BS in chemical engineering from the ...
A Guide to Peer Reviewing Journal Articles
Why peer review? As well as contributing to the quality of the research corpus in your field, conducting peer reviews can benefit your own career as ...
The Dos and Don'ts of Peer Reviewing - Eos.org
Reviews are best written in the third person to avoid sounding accusatory. Consider how your wording comes across from the authors' perspective ...
Sample Format For Reviewing A Journal Article
Write the literature review in the past tense; the research has already been completed. • The article cannot “do”, “find”, or “say” anything. The authors are ...
Understanding peer review - Author Services - Taylor & Francis
In particular, many of these journals do not make sure there is thorough peer review or editor feedback process in place. ... reviewing someone else's work. How ...
Reviewing: A Review - ACT Newsroom & Blog
The panel discussions are an invaluable experience. For me, I gain insight into what ACT is testing (English is a living language and its ...
Reviewing a paper for a journal (peer review) - YouTube
Practical tips, and recommendations on the attitude and style to adopt when writing a review of a journal article.
peer reviewing your first paper | patter - Pat Thomson
Before even beginning to read, the first thing to get clear about is the STANCE you have to take as a reviewer. Once you've clicked 'agree to ...
What's involved in reviewing an article? - Academia Stack Exchange
For a scientific, experimental paper, a peer reviewer should consider these issues: Are the topic and results appropriate for the journal?