The Basics of Reviewing A Research Study

These are some basic considerations when reviewing research studies, but this is not an exhaustive list. The guide provides, for each topic area, the elements ...

The Basics of Reviewing a Research Study - REL West

For each topic, the guide discusses elements to look for in a study, questions to ask about each element, why it matters to consider each ...

Step by Step Guide to Reviewing a Manuscript - Wiley Author Services

What is the main question addressed by the research? · How original is the topic? · Is the paper well written? · Are the conclusions consistent with the evidence ...

How to Review a Journal Article | University of Illinois Springfield

Evaluating Methods · How appropriate are the study design and methods for the purposes of the study? · How detailed are the methods being described? Is the author ...

What goes into a proper review of a paper?

Is existing literature taken into account properly? Give references to literature that you think is important to acknowledged but is not ...

How to Review a Scientific Paper in 10 Easy Steps | Proteintech Group

While reviewing a scientific paper, it's important to be mindful of ethical considerations. Evaluate whether the study adheres to ethical guidelines and ...

How do you review a journal research paper? - Quora

Read it to get a basic idea of what it covers. · Read the instructions to authors page on the Journals website, so you are aware of anything that ...

Chapter 9 Methods for Literature Reviews - NCBI

There is no preconceived plan to systematically review all of the literature although this can be done. Instead, researchers often present studies that are ...

How do I do a review of related literature (RRL)? | Editage Insights

Analyze and synthesize the information gathered, identifying gaps and areas for further research. For comprehensive assistance with your RRL and ...

How to conduct a review - Elsevier

Full length research article · Examine the importance of the research question addressed in the manuscript (e.g., are objectives and justification clearly stated ...

Literature Review Basics | University Writing & Speaking Center

A literature review synthesizes and analyzes previous research in a field to inform an audience and establish background knowledge.

Conduct a literature review | University of Arizona Libraries

What is the specific research question that your literature review helps to define? · Are there a maximum or minimum number of sources that your review should ...

Points to Consider When Reviewing Articles - Yale School of Medicine

Frequently Asked Questions · Original Research Articles. These manuscripts should present well-rounded studies reporting innovative advances that further ...

An Introduction to Reviewing Research Articles for Academic Journals

Does the introduction flow as a narrative? Does the literature review justify further study? Is the research question clearly stated? Methods, Was a validated ...

Review of a Research Article

The study's contribution to knowledge, theory, or practice in a field · The study's research design and methodology · The study's findings, in particular, how ...

LibGuides: Organizing and Creating Information: Literature Reviews

A literature review is a summary and synthesis of scholarly research on a specific topic. It should answer questions such as:

Understanding peer review - Author Services - Taylor & Francis

Peer review is the independent assessment of your research paper by experts in your field. The purpose of peer review is to evaluate the paper's quality and ...

How to Write a Literature Review | Guide, Examples, & Templates

If you are writing the literature review section of a dissertation or research paper, you will search for literature related to your research ...

Steps in the Literature Review Process

Define the research question (for more) · Determine inclusion/exclusion criteria · Choose databases and conduct the search · Review your results.

How to review a paper | IWA Publishing

Introduction · Does this provide context to the research and is the cited literature relevant? · Is the contribution of the paper within the wider literature ...