What can we do to improve the peer review system?

78% think that peer review is still the best way to allocate research funds, although half of them think that it lacks transparency and objectivity.

How do we improve peer review? - Research Information

For example, peer review as a discussion with a group of authors instead of being a linear process where a paper is sent to a peer reviewer and ...

Improving the peer-review process from the perspective of an author ...

Generally, invited reviewers do not know how many peers are involved in the review process and there is no interaction between reviewers. This ...

6 ways to improve the peer review experience

Peer reviews can also improve firms' efficiency by, for example, reducing excessive testing in low-risk areas, improving the use of technology ...

Improving the quality of Peer Review and accelerating the peer ...

Hence, it becomes essential that the editors should accelerate the peer review process, increase their reviewer's database, go for innovations and train new ...

How to improve scientific peer review: Four schools of thought

One way to make peer review more transparent is to publish the reports of peer reviewers, as well as the decision letters of editors and the ...

How could the peer review system be improved? - Quora

A very simple thing that can be done to improve peer review is to publish the referee reports alongside the paper.

The 4 ways peer review is broken (and how to fix them)

How to improve the peer-review process · 1. Create incentives for peer review. According to Carroll, formal training on how to conduct peer ...

Improving peer review: What reviewers can do - Oxford Academic

Do I believe it? Do I care? ... Manuscripts should clearly state the research question or clinical problem and then describe how the scholarly work was conducted.

A Beginner's Guide to the Peer Review System - Inside Higher Ed

Ask your advisor if you could assist them with an article they are reviewing to gain insight and experience into how the process works. Peer- ...

Best practice guidelines for peer review - Editor Resources

Key to this is to make sure that peer review reports are sourced from at least two independent referees, for every original research article we publish.

What makes a good or a bad peer review? Tips for excelling at ...

You should feel free to make suggestions about additional work that you think might improve the paper, but don't insist on this unless the paper ...

Top Tips for Peer Reviewers - Wiley Author Services

Your review should ultimately help the author improve the paper. So make sure you offer some constructive feedback, even if your recommendation ends up being to ...

The peer review system is broken. We asked academics how to fix it

Use more inclusive peer review recruitment strategies ... Many respondents also suggested journals can improve how they recruit reviewers, and ...

What's new in peer review? Initiatives by the academic community

There is no clear definition for OPR, but it broadly refers to a peer review model wherein elements of the peer review process are made publicly ...

Improving the peer review experience for reviewers and authors

In today's landscape of increasing publication volumes and large amounts of information, peer review is more important than ever.

Improving peer review: What authors can do - Oxford Academic

Before beginning the process of responding to comments and revising the manuscript, check the author or resubmission guidelines of the journal. Whether on the ...

Understanding peer review - Author Services - Taylor & Francis

There are also practical reasons why peer review is beneficial to you, the author. The peer review process can alert you to any errors in your work, or gaps in ...

Ask The Chefs: How Can We Improve the Article Review and ...

Peer review is an intrinsically complex process, involving millions of reviews every year. No one sees what the others are doing so it is easy ...

Understanding the peer review process: A step-by-step guide for ...

Researchers should carefully select a journal that aligns with the scope and focus of their study. It is essential to review the journal's ...