How to write a thorough peer review
So You've Been Asked To Review A Paper... | Dr S J Thomson
A Few Things To Keep In Mind · Remember we're all (supposed to be) on the same side · Don't write anything you wouldn't say to the authors in real ...
How to peer review: practical advice for early career researchers
When starting the review, make sure to download all the files, not limited to the main manuscript, but also the figures and tables (sometimes provided ...
Guidelines For Article Reviewers - F1000Research
Read the article fully - please read the full text of the article and view all associated figures, tables and data; · Be thorough - a peer review report should ...
How to Conduct a Scientific Peer Review - YouTube
Have you received an invitation from a journal to review a manuscript, but are unsure how to write a review? In this video, I provide some ...
Peer Review Guidance: How Do You Write a Good Review?
Arguably, the most important characteristic of a good peer reviewer is to be an advocate for the author. Benos et al put it best when they wrote ...
How to write a thorough peer review
Scientists receive too little peer-review training. Here's one method for effectively peer-reviewing papers, says Mathew Stiller-Reeve.
How to Receive and Respond to Peer Review Feedback - PLOS
Write your response, take a break, and come back to it. Re-read your comments and make sure they come across calm and professional. If you're ...
I peer reviewed a paper and found it to be sound - technically and ...
Just being well-written and correct is not enough. Why should someone read the paper? What are the new things that we learn thanks to this ...
Peer Review: Why is it important? | ZB MED - PUBLISSO
Peer review involves subjecting the author's scholarly work and research to the scrutiny of other experts in the same field to check its validity.
How to become a peer reviewer: 5 Considerations for first-time ...
5 Key considerations for first-time peer reviewers · 1. Understand the peer review process before agreeing to review · 2. Read the manuscript ...
Peer review-how to decide what to recommend
Point out the types of writing concerns you see, mention the areas to substantiate more if possible, and recommend publication. Unless you're ...
Credit for Peer Review: What is it Worth? - The Scholarly Kitchen
That came by writing thorough reviews whenever being honored with a request. There's always time to do a review, don't kid yourself. If it ...
How to Write the Perfect Peer Review | Orvium
How to prepare before writing a peer review · 1. Understand the purpose of the review. The first step in preparing to write a peer review is to ...
What should i know before starting to write a Peer Review?
When you write the report, don't be the dreaded reviewer B - it can be very easy to focus on criticism and negative points, but remember your ...
What Is Peer Review? | Types & Examples - Scribbr
Peer review, sometimes referred to as refereeing, is the process of evaluating submissions to an academic journal.
How I Peer Review Research Papers - César Soto Valero
**Positive Aspects** Bullet list in decreasing order of relevance. Example: - The topic is relevant and timely. - The idea is novel and fills a ...
Worst peer review experience? : r/AskAcademia - Reddit
They often do it because the text being delivered is difficult to read. One might be writing in long, run-on, multi-clausal sentences. Or one ...
How to Be A Good Peer Reviewer - The Scholarly Kitchen
Do not write a few simple statements filled with your opinions, rather make sure your feedback is robust and informative. If you know additional ...
How to Write a Peer Review Report without Being a Jerk
Check the existing review criteria · Get a sense of the paper on its own terms · “Academic writing feels fun again” — IoF author Heath Fogg Davis.
How to write a superb literature review - Nature
My reasons for writing one can include the chance to contribute insights to the scientific community and identify opportunities for my research.