Reviewing a review
Peer Reviews - ACS Researcher Resources
Browse the sections below to learn how you can become a reviewer for ACS journals, along with essential information for both authors and reviewers.
My peer review process - William XQ Ngiam
The standards and expectations in the peer review process were only revealed to me when I began submitting papers and conducting peer reviews in ...
... reviewing each other's work and providing feedback and suggestions for revision. Rather than a means of critiquing each other's work, peer review is ...
Reviewing Reviews in The Art Bulletin - Taylor & Francis Online
book reviews in The Art Bulletin represented an early window into the field at large, art history as an active discipline—one with its own ...
Reviewed to Reviewing: Responsibilities, Considerations, and ...
Much like the author side, your experience as a reviewer will vary from journal to journal. Some will be more relaxed, and some will have strict ...
How to Write a Peer Review - PLOS
... reviewer instructions or check with the journal first before submitting your review. If you are reviewing for a journal that does not offer ...
The peer review section will not appear on your personal (private) ORCID record until a trusted organization has added a review to your ORCID record. You must ...
Peer-Reviewing Journal Articles: Should You Do It? Sharing What I ...
If you do decide to review a paper, make sure that you can give it the time it deserves. The paper I reviewed earlier this year was pretty short ...
Reviewing, Evaluating and Editing - SpringerLink
In this chapter, we will look at different types of journal peer review. We will address the responsibilities of peer reviewers toward the authors and editor.
Guidelines for Reviewers - Review Commons
Co-reviewing. Review Commons believes that early career researchers (ECRs) can play a valuable role in reviewing, provided that the principal reviewer has ...
I try to be a careful reviewer and I invest time in my reviews. I will do my best to make sure I understand the manuscript before I write feedback. I offer ...
Reviewing Peer Review - Science
Many legal decisions and regulations also depend on peer-reviewed science. Thus, thorough, expert review of research results—without ...
PREreview: Open preprint reviews. For all researchers.
Open preprint reviews. For all researchers. Provide and receive constructive feedback on preprints from an international community of your peers.
How to Review an Article - The Science PT
Here is a template you can use for reviewing an article by yourself or with your friends. One of the most common questions I get is along the lines of,
A quick guide to reviewing papers quick | by Sauvik Das - Medium
If the ad-hoc issue is critically important (e.g., if it is the difference between an accept or reject), then add it to your review. If it is ...
Co-review with a colleague - IOPscience - Publishing Support
Allow early career researchers to build their peer review competency; Provide early career researchers with benefits and rewards for reviewing; Ensure full ...
Managing Peer Review in Web of Science researcher profiles
Writing Community reviews is a good way to demonstrate your expertise to editors, other reviewers, and authors. It is also a great way to log the literature you ...
Editors send papers to reviewers with different expertise and from different locations, deliberately seeking reviews that provide an in-depth critique. All ...
Paper Peer Reviewing - Learning Indico
Introduction. This short video explains the Peer Review process and the reviewer's and judge's role in Indico: The Peer Reviewing module allows you to.
Reviewer Resources - Academy of Management
Doing so puts the action editor in the awkward position of rejecting a paper that—seemingly—has positive reviews. Non-English Native Authors: ...