One Interview Reviewer's Advice
The overall opinion and general comments on the article is essential. Comments should be courteous and constructive, and should not include ad hominem remarks ...
The art of suggesting reviewers - Cell Mentor
... guidance on the art suggesting peer reviewers for ... single one of the reviewers that our authors suggest, for every single manuscript.
Reviewer 2 Must Be Stopped! | Facebook
The one who goes on an on about how the method you used sucks (except s/he misread the paper and you didn't use that method at all)... ... Don't freak out if your ...
Reviewer Guidelines | British Journal of Dermatology
Reviewers have 1 week to respond to an invitation to review a manuscript. Once you have accepted the invitation to review you will receive an email with ...
When to Identify Non-Preferred Reviewers - Methods Blog
We understand that it is unlikely that every question you have will be answered by our guidance (although we hope that we can address at least a ...
Reviewer Guide - Scholastica Help Desk
DO: · List positive aspects of the paper before getting into the improvements that could be made · Use the journal-provided reviewer form to guide ...
6) Make your response about you, not the reviewer. ... Your editor may ask you to write a response to the reader reports, addressing the readers' ...
This week Garrett Witt from Dead Head Reviews.
But today we're going to flip the mold, having an author interview a book reviewer. ... I'm inspired by every one of you who help me ...
This page provides everything you need to write a peer review. Learn the basics of peer review and get helpful tips for handling reviewer tasks, ...
Response to reviewers - APA Style
This guidance is new to the 7th edition. Sample response to reviewers. This is a sample response to reviewers. It includes suggested language for responding ...
Selecting Reviewers - ASHA Journals Academy
The editor should select someone who has a good track record of fair reviews returned promptly, who can review the manuscript without professional or personal ...
Anonymous peer reviewers: the real heroes of academia - ECHER
We all know how important the work of peer reviewer is. What, in your opinion, is the difference between a good peer reviewer and a not-so-good ...
Manuscript Reviews - Manning Publications
help us make a good book—be a manuscript reviewer. Manuscript Reviewers read chapter drafts and provide feedback that helps us and the authors improve them.
Before your accept | Nature Reviews Bioengineering
... a reviewer returns their report typically within two weeks. ... If you are unsure of whether a factor is a competing interest, contact the editor for guidance.
Guidelines for Reviewers - Journal of Emergency and Critical Care ...
1. Peer review mode · 2. Transparent peer review · 3. The role of reviewers · 4. To become a reviewer · 5. Guidance for peer reviewers.
(2) Peer review: a manuscript will be reviewed by at least two reviewers. The peer review process will help editors make better decisions. (3) Editor decision ...
Responding to Peer Reviewers: You Can't Always Say What ... - AJE
Of course, you do not have to agree with every suggestion that a reviewer makes, but responding politely will help you when you want to refuse a ...
Reviewer Guide - Theory and Practice in Language Studies
1. Fairness of Review. The judgments should be objective. · 2. Type of Peer Review. Peer review is obtaining advice on individual manuscripts from reviewers ...
How to Deal with an Insufferable Code Reviewer - DaedTech
A Bit of Perspective on Code Reviews and Code Reviewers. Before going into any advice, let's consider the subject of code review itself.
Reviewer guide | Development | The Company of Biologists
The editor may also be in touch directly with specific questions that will help him/her to make a decision on the manuscript. Reviewers wishing to identify ...